PHILIP SERVICES CORP. JOHN DOE 1 a.k.a. Addicted 2PHV et al.
and
Plaintiff Defendants

Court File No. 4582 / 98

ONTARIO COURT (GENERAL DIVISION)

Proceeding commenced at Hamilton

ORDER

TURKSTRA MAZZA ASSOCIATES
Barristers and Solicitors
15 Bold Street
Hamilton, Ontario
L8P 1T3

Douglas Hodgson
(905) 529-3476
(905) 529-3663 (fax)

Solicitors for the Plaintiff
(Please see variance to this court order granted July 7, 1998)

Court File No. 4592 / 98

ONTARIO COURT (GENERAL DIVISION)

THE HONOURABLE
MR. JUSTICE BORKOVICH		       )      
)		 WEDNESDAY, THE 24TH DAY
OF JUNE, 1998
BETWEEN:

PHILIP SERVICES CORP.

Plaintiff/Applicant

-and-

JOHN DOE 1 a.k.a. Addicted2PHV,
JOHN DOE 2 a.k.a. alreadygored,
JOHN DOE 3 a.k.a. Angelofthelaw,
JOHN DOE 4 a.k.a. Ben_Hurr98,
JOHN DOE 5 a.k.a. brokerr39 and Broker39,
JOHN DOE 6 a.k.a. Coma_Cozy,
JOHN DOE 7 a.k.a. CountBuster,
JOHN DOE 8 a.k.a. cstew,
JOHN DOE 9 a.k.a. Imm1tya,
JOHN DOE 10 a.k.a. Imshort65,
JOHN DOE 11 a.k.a. inthebunker,
JOHN DOE 12 a.k.a. mobhit,
JOHN DOE 13 a.k.a. mreecs,
JOHN DOE 14 a.k.a. Paul Palango,
JOHN DOE 15 a.k.a. PJ_21,
JOHN DOE 16 a.k.a. Realdic,
JOHN DOE 17 a.k.a. sava_urasa,
JOHN DOE 18 a.k.a. scrappym,
JOHN DOE 19 a.k.a. skeptic666 and skeptik666,
JOHN DOE 20 a.k.a. somnific_no_more,
JOHN DOE 21 a.k.a. Stucklikeglue and stucklikeglue,
JOHN DOE 22 a.k.a. SunTzu22,
JOHN DOE 23 a.k.a. THEPHVPOSTMAN,
JOHN DOE 24 a.k.a. tigerstar666,
JOHN DOE 25 a.k.a. twickewnbam,
JOHN DOE 26 a.k.a. wentworth_guy,
AND PERSONS UNKNOWN

Defendants/Respondents

ORDER to Weslink Datalink Corporation

THIS MOTION, made by Philip Services Corp. for a preservation order, for the answers to questions and for the sealing of this file, made ex parte without notice, was hard this day at Hamilton, Ontario.

ON READING the Motion Record filed in these proceedings and on hearing the submissions of counsel for the Applicant Philip Services Corp. appearing in person,

1.
THIS COURT ORDERS Weslink Datalink Corporation to preserve all electronic, computerized, and computer produced data, or data in any other form - whether printed, recorded, copied, or electronic - related to the persons who were using the Internet Protocol addresses at the dates and times listed on Schedule A including without limitation:

a.
logs of calls or log-ons made,

b.
names, addresses, modem telephone numbers, bills, records, and data about the persons sending the messages listed and for all other messages sent by such persons through the internet providers,

c.
names, addresses, modem telephone numbers, bills, records, and data about the persons with the e-mail addresses listed on Schedule A,

d.
names, models, registration numbers, serial numbers, and other identifying information concerning the computers and modems used by the persons.

2.
THIS COURT GRANTS LEAVE to the applicant Philip Services Corp. to examine for discovery Weslink Datalink Corporation.

3.
THIS COURT ORDERS Weslink Data Corporation to answer questions #1 and #2 listed on Schedule B within 10 days.

4.
THIS COURT ORDERS Weslink Data Corporation to answer question #3 and #4 listed on Schedule B within 20 days.

5.
THIS COURT ORDERS Weslink Data Corporation to provide authenticated printouts of the data used to determine the answers to the questions listed on Schedule B.

6.
THIS COURT ORDERS Weslink Datalink Corporation together with their employees and agents not to publish, speak about, or distribute this order and any documents provided with the Order until such time as the Examination of Weslink Datalink Corporation has been completed and the questions ordered to be answered herein have been answered or until further order of this Honourable Court.

ENTERED AT HAMILTON
In Book No. 114
as Document No. 125
on JUN 24 1998
by __(initials)__		 __(signed)__

SCHEDULE A

Weslink Datalink Corporation
(Western Co-Axial Limited)
1603 Main Street West
Hamilton, Ontario
L8S 1E6

IP Address Message # Date and Time EDT Alias Alternate Name Email Address
204.50.192.122 991 6 May - 2:11 pm somnific_no_more somnific_no_more [email protected]
204.50.192.123 1431 26 May - 11:29 am Stucklikeglue somnific_no_more [email protected]
204.50.197.116 763 28 Apr - 10:40 pm SunTzu22 somnific_no_more [email protected]
204.50.192.222 783 20 Apr - 7:45 pm SunTzu22 somnific_no_more [email protected]
204.50.192.61 936 5 May 7:23 am SunTzu22 somnific_no_more [email protected]
204.50.192.151 1007 6 May - 5:56 pm SunTzu22 somnific_no_more [email protected]
204.50.192.55 1021 6 May - 9:42 pm SunTzu22 somnific_no_more [email protected]
204.50.192.59 1183 10 May - 6:09 am SunTzu22 somnific_no_more [email protected]
204.50.192.214 1206 11 May - 5:52 pm SunTzu22 somnific_no_more [email protected]
203.50.192.214 1232 13 May - 1:11 pm SunTzu22 somnific_no_more [email protected]
204.50.192.98 1274 15 May - 3:57 pm SunTzu22 somnific_no_more [email protected]
204.50.192.78 1284 15 May - 8:49 pm SunTzu22 somnific_no_more [email protected]
204.50.192.54 1408 24 May - 8:54 pm SunTzu22 somnific_no_more [email protected]

SCHEDULE B

Questions to be Answered by Internet Providers

Subscribers by IP address

1.
Please provide the names, addresses, telephone numbers, e-mail addresses, and all information known to you concerning the make, model, type, registration number, or other characteristics of the computer and modem of the persons (you "subscriber") who had the Internet protocol addresses belonging to you the internet provider at the times and dates listed on Schedule A. Please list the information by Internet scubscriber, address, and pseudonym.

Subscribers by E-mail address

2.
Please provide the names, addresses, telephone numbers, and all information known to you concerning the make, model, type, registration number, or other characteristics of the computer and modem of the persons with the e-mail addresses listed on Schedule A.

IP addresses for all messages

3.
Please list the internet protocol addresses used by any of the subscribers listed in questions one and two above at the times and dates listed under your internet provider name on Schedule C. Please list by subscriber, date, and time of use.

All IP addresses used by subscribers

4.
Please list the times and dates on which the subscribers listed in the questions one and two used your internet provider service during 1998 and the internet protocol address used on teach of those occasions.

SCHEDULE C

somnific_no_more messages by "somnific_no_more" posted to Yahoo!PHV board via Weslink:

YAHOO!PHV
"IP" ADDRESS
 		 MESSAGE NUMBERS DATE & TIME
WESLINK
70025 Apr 98 12:15 pm EDT
70926 Apr 98 5:14 am EDT
71826 Apr 98 7:34 pm EDT
8462 May 98 9:13 am EDT
8752 May 98 11:50 pm EDT
8863 May 98 11:45 am EDT
204.50.192.1229916 May 98 2:11 pm EDT
9936 May 98 2:21 pm EDT
10847 May 98 8:12 pm EDT
11208 May 98 6:25 am EDT
11288 May 98 11:17 am EDT
11358 May 98 1:12 pm EDT
11428 May 98 3:08 pm EDT
11458 May 98 4:09 pm EDT
11548 May 98 5:38 pm EDT
11568 May 98 5:46 pm EDT
11739 May 98 11:25 am EDT
122513 May 98 4:53 am EDT
123713 May 98 4:10 pm EDT
124613 May 98 9:18 pm EDT
125114 May 98 9:57 am EDT
126014 May 98 5:50 pm EDT
156329 May 98 5:30 pm EDT

SCHEDULE C

Stucklikeglue/stucklikeglue messages by "somnific_no_more" posted to Yahoo!PHV board via Weslink:

YAHOO!PHV
"IP" ADDRESS
 		 MESSAGE NUMBERS DATE & TIME
WESLINK
 
204.50.192.123143126 May 98 12:29 am EDT
143326 May 98 1:54 pm EDT
143726 May 98 4:39 pm EDT
144026 May 98 5:37 pm EDT
146627 May 98 9:32 am EDT
147527 May 98 2:10 pm EDT
147927 May 98 4:26 pm EDT
151128 May 98 12:02 pm EDT
151528 May 98 1:20 pm EDT
151828 May 98 2:32 pm EDT
154229 May 98 7:31 am EDT
154629 May 98 9:59 am EDT
156229 May 98 3:02 pm EDT
16301 Jun 98 3:17 pm EDT
16361 Jun 98 6:12 pm EDT
16652 Jun 98 3:16 pm EDT
17505 Jun 98 12:37 pm EDT
17847 Jun 98 1:45 pm EDT
17907 Jun 98 9:00 pm EDT
193612 Jun 98 7:39 pm EDT
193712 Jun 98 7:41 pm EDT
194012 Jun 98 10:53 pm EDT
199816 Jun 98 9:17 pmm EDT

SCHEDULE C

SunTzu22 messages by "somnific_no_more" posted to Yahoo!PHV board via Weslink:

YAHOO!PHV
"IP" ADDRESS
 		 MESSAGE NUMBERS DATE & TIME
WESLINK
73127 Apr 98 3:18 pm EDT
74127 Apr 98 7:03 pm EDT
204.50.197.11676328 Apr 98 10:40 pm EDT
77429 Apr 98 1:45 pm EDT
78029 Apr 98 7:09 pm EDT
204.50.192.22278329 Apr 98 7:45 pm EDT
79029 Apr 98 10:28 pm EDT
79330 Apr 98 9:31 am EDT
79830 Apr 98 3:34 am EDT
80430 Apr 98 8:21 pm EDT
80830 Apr 98 10:00 pm EDT
8311 May 98 8:01 pm EDT
9084 May 98 1:47 pm EDT
9184 May 98 7:05 pm EDT
204:50.192.619365 May 98 7:23 am EDT
9595 May 98 9:35 pm EDT
9966 May 98 3:01 pm EDT
204.50.192.15110076 May 98 5:56 pm EDT
10136 May 98 7:35 pm EDT
204.50.192.5510216 May 98 9:42 pm EDT
10607 May 98 11:27 am EDT
11759 May 98 1:22 pm EDT
204.50.192.59118310 May 98 6:09 am EDT
120011 May 98 4:26 pm EDT
204.50.192.214120611 May 98 5:52 pm EDT
204.50.192.214123213 May 98 1:11 pm EDT
204.50.192.98127415 May 98 3:57 pm EDT
204.50.192.78128415 May 98 8:49 pm EDT
129917 May 98 12:52 pm EDT
140824 May 98 8:54 pm EDT